People buy a soundproof door expecting a product and get a system. The leaf is only one part of it, and in most installations it is not the part that decides the outcome.
Here is what is actually happening, in the order it matters.
Sound takes the easiest route, always
This single idea explains almost every disappointing acoustic door. Sound behaves like water running down a wall: it finds the cheapest path through and takes it. A heavy, expensive, beautifully built leaf with a ten millimetre gap under it will perform roughly like a far cheaper door, because the air gap is the cheapest path and the leaf is irrelevant to the sound going under it.
So the first question about any door is not what it is made of. It is where the holes are.
Mass: real, but expensive and limited
Heavy things are harder to vibrate, so heavy panels pass less sound. The relationship is unhelpfully steep, though: doubling the mass of a panel buys you roughly six decibels. Six decibels is audible and worth having, but doubling the mass of a door means doubling its weight, which means heavier hinges, a stronger frame and a leaf that is awkward to hang.
This is why you cannot simply build your way out of a noise problem by making the door thicker. Past a point the weight costs more than the decibels are worth.
Absorption: what the wool is for
Inside a hollow cavity, sound rattles around and comes out the other side. Fill the cavity with something fibrous and dense — mineral wool, typically — and the air movement inside the fibres turns a little of that energy into heat.
Two things get misunderstood here. Density matters more than thickness. A loosely stuffed cavity behaves much like an empty one. And the gain is modest: filling a door cavity well is worth a few decibels, not twenty. It is worth doing; it is not the headline.
Damping: why layers beat one thick slab
Every panel has frequencies at which it would rather vibrate than resist, and at those frequencies it passes sound almost as if it were not there. A single stiff slab has a pronounced one of these, usually somewhere unhelpful.
Build the same thickness as layers of different density — timber facing, engineered board, wool, board, timber — and no single resonance dominates. That is the real reason acoustic doors are sandwiches rather than slabs, and it is the part of the design that cheap imitations leave out, because it does not show.
And then the seals, which quietly decide everything
A door has four lines where it meets the frame, and a double door has five because the two leaves also meet each other. Each unsealed line is an open path.
- Head and jambs — compression gaskets, unbroken where they pass the hinges. A seal that stops short at each hinge is three small holes.
- The meeting stile, on a double door. It must be rebated so the leaves overlap. Two flat edges closing against each other are a full-height slot, however neatly they are planed.
- The threshold. The big one, and the one most often skipped because it costs more and takes longer. An automatic drop seal sits in a housing in the bottom of the leaf, drops as the door closes and lifts as it opens. The alternative — a raised threshold strip — works acoustically and is a trip hazard and a wheelchair problem.
The difference between an unsealed solid-core door and the same door fully sealed is larger than the difference between a cheap core and an expensive one. It is also cheaper. If you take one thing from this article, take that.
Flanking: the limit of what a door can do
There is a ceiling on any door, and it is set by everything around it. Sound travels through the wall, over the ceiling void, under the floor, and through the gap where the frame meets the masonry. Fitting a 45 dB door into a 30 dB wall gets you a 30 dB room and a large bill.
Before upgrading a door, it is worth standing in the quiet room and listening for where the noise is strongest. If it is the same everywhere, it is the wall. If it is loudest at the doorway, the door is worth doing.
Where to spend, in order
- Close the gaps. Seals, meeting stile rebate, drop seal. Cheapest and biggest.
- Get the frame right. Solid fixing to structure, packed and sealed at the masonry junction. A frame that moves unseals the door.
- Get a solid core. Anything is better than hollow.
- Add mass and layered damping. Worth it, with diminishing returns.
- Buy a tested doorset, if a number is genuinely required of you.
Most people arrive at this list from the bottom and run out of money before reaching the top, which is exactly the wrong way round.
Further reading
Specifying a double leaf solid wood door · The 5′9″ × 8′ acoustic doorset · Rw, STC and what to ask for by country