Why Small Fabrication Jobs Quietly Lose Money

A two-window job at your normal rate is usually sold below cost, and the reason is not the rate. It is setup, travel and the hours nobody counts.

Every fabrication shop has the same pattern in its books, whether or not anyone has looked for it. The big jobs make money. The medium jobs make a little. The small jobs — two windows, one grill, a single gate — make nothing, and a fair number lose.

The owner usually knows this as a feeling and prices as if it were not true, because the rate card has one rate on it.

What a rate per square foot assumes

Your rate was worked out, consciously or not, from jobs of a certain size. Embedded in it is an assumption about how much material you buy at once, how many pieces come off one setup, and how many square feet a trip to site covers.

A small job breaks all three assumptions at the same time, and the rate carries on as if nothing happened.

The four costs that do not scale down

Travel

A site visit to quote, a visit to measure, a trip to deliver, a day to install. For a twenty-window job that is spread across six hundred square feet. For a two-window job it is spread across thirty-two. The travel did not get cheaper.

Setup

Changing a saw setting, re-fixing a jig, mixing a small quantity of something, cleaning a gun. On a batch this is amortised across forty pieces. On two it is amortised across two.

Cutting waste

Standard lengths do not divide neatly into small jobs. On a large order you nest the cuts and the offcuts get used. On a small one you buy a full length, use half, and the rest sits in the corner for a year.

Your own time

Quoting, following up, answering calls, arranging the visit, raising the bill, chasing the balance. This is roughly the same for a ₹12,000 job as for a ₹1,20,000 job, and in a small shop it is the owner's time, which is the most expensive time in the building.

Running the numbers honestly

Take your last small job and add up, in rupees:

  • Material actually consumed, including the offcut you will not use.
  • Workshop hours at what you pay, plus setup.
  • Every trip — fuel, vehicle, and the people in it.
  • Installation hours.
  • Your own hours on quoting, calls and billing, at some honest rate.
  • A share of rent, power and tools.

Most shops doing this exercise for the first time find the small job landed somewhere between breaking even and losing fifteen percent — on work that was invoiced at the normal rate and felt, at the time, perfectly ordinary.

Four ways out, in order of how well they work

A minimum order value

The simplest and most effective. Decide the number below which a job is not worth the trip, say it out loud when the enquiry arrives, and hold it. You will lose some enquiries. Those were the ones costing you money.

A separate small-job rate

Not a penalty — an honest reflection of cost. A rate per square foot that applies above, say, a hundred square feet, and a higher one below it. Customers accept this readily when it is stated up front, because it matches their intuition that small orders cost more per unit everywhere else too.

A visit and setup charge as its own line

Transparent, and it survives negotiation better than a padded rate. When a customer asks you to come down, the rate can move and the visit charge does not.

Batching by area

Collect the small jobs in one locality and do them on the same day. One trip, one setup, three customers. This is the only option that reduces the real cost rather than repricing it.

The one you should resist

Taking the small job at a loss because it "might lead to bigger work". Sometimes it does. Mostly the customer who wanted two windows wanted two windows. If you are going to subsidise an enquiry, decide that deliberately and know what it cost you, rather than discovering it in a year's accounts.

What to measure if you want to know for certain

Two numbers, kept for three months, settle this argument permanently: man-days per job and trips per job. Both are easy to record and neither requires accounting. Plot them against job value and the shape of your business becomes uncomfortable and extremely useful.

Further reading

Getting paid on time · How to quote aluminium windows · Recording man-days per job

Get Expert Installers for Why Small Fabrication Jobs Quietly Lose Money
Share your requirement — we connect you with trusted, verified installers.
A free client account is created for you automatically — login details are emailed so you can track your requirement.

Looking for professional installation services?

Find Installers Register as Installer